Agenda and minutes

Planning Committee
Monday, 14th October, 2019 3.00 pm

Venue: Committee Room 1, Town Hall, Rose Hill, Chesterfield S40 1LP

Contact: Charlotte Kearsey  01246 345236

Items
No. Item

56.

Apologies for Absence

Minutes:

Apologies for absence were received from Councillors Borrell, Davenport, Kelly and G Falconer.

57.

Declarations of Members' and Officers' Interests Relating to Items on the Agenda

Minutes:

Councillor Bingham declared an interest in agenda item 4(3)(CHE/19/00242/FUL - Use of land as open storage (use class b8), retention of fill material and associated landscaping works. (flood risk statement received 26.06.2019, ex and proposed sections received on 16.07.2019 and landscape master plan received on 12.08.2019), on land at land at Whittington Industrial Estate, Station Lane, New Whittington. Derbyshire S43 2BP) as he had taken a neutral role on the matter in liaising between the applicant and local residents and wished to retain this position.

 

Councillor Brady declared an interest in agenda item 4(5) (CHE/19/00401/FUL - Change of use from storage to provide fitness facilities at A-Rock House, 133 Baden Powell Road, Chesterfield, S40 2RL) as he was related to the applicant through marriage.

 

The Development Management and Conservation Manager declared an interest in agenda item 4(2) (CHE/17/00469/OUT - Residential development of up to 650 dwelling (inc. elderly care and specialist accommodation), a local centre (inc. local retail, health facilities and services), open space, community garden extension (inc. community building and parking) and associated infrastructure - revised information received (flood risk assessment April 2018, viability assessment July 2018, archaeological assessment November 2018, design & access statement/ masterplan February 2019, revised masterplan June 2019 and overarching wsi for archaeology September 2019) at land south of Worksop Road, Mastin Moor, Chesterfield, Derbyshire for Chatsworth Settlement Trustees) as his parents live near to the site.

 

The Principal Planner declared an interest in agenda item 4(6) (  CHE/19/00394/REM – Approval of reserved matters following CHE/0389/0210 and CHE/0892/0496 as varied by CHE/16/00219/NMA; CHE/16/00317/REM1, CHE/16/00318/REM1, CHE/16/00319/REM1 and CHE/16/00320/REM1 at land at The Brushes, Sheffield Road, Chesterfield for David Lloyd Developments LTD and  CHE/19/00456/REM1 - Variation of condition 52 on application CHE/0892/0496 as varied by CHE/16/00219/NMA; CHE/16/00317/REM1, CHE/16/00318/REM1, CHE/16/00319/REM1 and CHE/16/00320/REM1 to substitute drawings to enable relocation of approved phase 1 components within the consented development areas and facilitate revised phasing at land at The Brushes, Sheffield Road, Chesterfield for Birchall Properties LTD.) as some objectors were known to her socially.

 

Councillors Simmons and Caulfield declared an interest in item 4(6) (CHE/19/00394/REM AND CHE/19/00456/REM1 -

(A)  CHE/19/00394/REM – approval of reserved matters following CHE/0389/0210 AND CHE/0892/0496 as varied by CHE/16/00219/NMA; CHE/16/00317/REM1, CHE/16/00318/REM1, CHE/16/00319/REM1 AND CHE/16/00320/REM1 at land At The Brushes, Sheffield Road, Chesterfield For David Lloyd Developments Ltd.

(B)  CHE/19/00456/REM1 - variation of condition 52 on application CHE/0892/0496 as varied by CHE/16/00219/NMA; CHE/16/00317/REM1, CHE/16/00318/REM1, CHE/16/00319/REM1 and CHE/16/00320/REM1 to substitute drawings to enable relocation of approved phase 1 components within the consented development areas and facilitate revised phasing at land at The Brushes, Sheffield Road, Chesterfield for Birchall Properties Ltd.) as they knew the applicant socially in their respective roles as Mayor and Mayoress.

58.

Minutes of Planning Committee pdf icon PDF 197 KB

Minutes:

RESOLVED -

 

That the Minutes of the meeting of the Planning Committee held on 23 September, 2019 be signed by the Chair as a true record.

59.

Applications for Planning Permission - Plans Determined by the Committee pdf icon PDF 43 KB

Additional documents:

Minutes:

*The Committee considered the under-mentioned applications in light of reports by the Development Management and Conservation Manager and resolved as follows:-

 

Councillors Caulfield and Simmons left the meeting at this point as they had not attended the site visits so were precluded from participating in the debate and making decisions on the applications to be determined by Committee.

 

The Principal Planner had declared an interest in the following item and left the meeting at this point.

 

CHE/19/00394/REM AND CHE/19/00456/REM1 -

 

(A)  CHE/19/00394/REM – APPROVAL OF RESERVED MATTERS FOLLOWING CHE/0389/0210 AND CHE/0892/0496 AS VARIED BY CHE/16/00219/NMA; CHE/16/00317/REM1, CHE/16/00318/REM1, CHE/16/00319/REM1 AND CHE/16/00320/REM1 AT LAND AT THE BRUSHES, SHEFFIELD ROAD, CHESTERFIELD FOR DAVID LLOYD DEVELOPMENTS LTD.

 

(B)  CHE/19/00456/REM1 - VARIATION OF CONDITION 52 ON APPLICATION CHE/0892/0496 AS VARIED BY CHE/16/00219/NMA; CHE/16/00317/REM1, CHE/16/00318/REM1, CHE/16/00319/REM1 AND CHE/16/00320/REM1 TO SUBSTITUTE DRAWINGS TO ENABLE RELOCATION OF APPROVED PHASE 1 COMPONENTS WITHIN THE CONSENTED DEVELOPMENT AREAS AND FACILITATE REVISED PHASING AT LAND AT THE BRUSHES, SHEFFIELD ROAD, CHESTERFIELD FOR BIRCHALL PROPERTIES LTD.

 

In accordance with Minute No. 299 (2001/2002) Geoff Musgrove (objector), Jim Allsop (objector), Alex Dale on behalf of Unstone Parish Council (objector) and Rupert Carr (applicant’s agent) addressed the meeting.

 

(A)  CHE/19/00394/REM

 

Approve subject to the conditions of the outline planning permission CHE/0389/0210 and CHE/0892/0496 as varied by CHE/16/00219/NMA; CHE/16/00317/REM1, CHE/16/00318/REM1, CHE/16/00319/REM1 and CHE/16/00320/REM1and subject to the following additional conditions:

 

1.  Prior to commencement of development on the site a full ecological survey of the application site shall be undertaken by a suitably qualified ecologist and which shall be submitted to the local planning authority for consideration with the Derbyshire Wildlife Trust. The submission shall include any necessary mitigation measures and the use of an Ecological Clerk of Works to oversee the site works. The details subsequently agreed in writing shall be carried out as part of the development hereby agreed.

 

2.  Only the proposed phase 1 car parking area shown on drawing 2018-02-PL-100B is approved by this permission subject to the submission of the further following details being submitted to the local planning authority for consideration:

 

·        Screen bunding;

·        Soft landscaping;

·        Drainage;

·        Hard surfacing and mitigation of potential gas migration;

·        Lighting.

 

The car parking area shall thereafter be implemented on site in accord with the details, or any amendment to those details which may be required, which are agreed in writing by the local planning authority and which shall thereafter be retained.

 

3.  There shall be no vehicular or pedestrian access to the proposed car parking area from the golf course access from Sheffield Road to the north of the site.

 

4.  The karting track facility shall not be used by petrol or diesel motorised vehicles.

 

5.  No payment shall be made to park in the proposed car park. A Management Plan setting out how the car park is to operate shall be submitted to the local planning authority for consideration. The agreed details shall be implemented as part of the development and the parking area shall be made available for use in accordance with  ...  view the full minutes text for item 59.

60.

Applications for Planning Permission - Plans Determined by the Development Management and Conservation Manager (P140D) pdf icon PDF 43 KB

Additional documents:

Minutes:

*The Development Management and Conservation Manager reported that pursuant to the authority delegated to him, he had determined the under-mentioned applications subject to the necessary conditions:-

 

(a)   Approvals

 

CHE/18/00559/RET

Change of use from A1 (Retail) use to A3 (Restaurants and Cafes) and ancillary takeaway at 11 Beetwell Street Chesterfield S40 1SH for Mr Ricky Marples

 

CHE/19/00174/FUL

Erection of single storey rear extension.  Revised plans received 30.05.2019 at 16 Booker Close Inkersall S43 3WA for Samantha Townsend

 

CHE/19/00244/COU

Change of use from office to flat. New information received 25.07.2019 at Flat 3 77 South Street North New Whittington Derbyshire S43 2AA for Mrs Marietta Thacker

 

CHE/19/00284/LBC

Listed Building Consent for installation of temporary internal ply security screens to the ground floor and easily accessible first floor windows at Tapton House Brimington Road Tapton Derbyshire S41 0TD for Chesterfield Borough Council

 

CHE/19/00353/FUL

Sub-division of the former Bristol StreetMotors building, to provide 3 separate units for use as car-sales (Unit A, Sui-generis use); a storage facility/trade-counter (Unit B, B8 use) and a car-repair workshop including MOT testing (Unit C, B2 Use); and with associated alterations to the elevations and revisions to the car-parking layout at Bristol Street Motors Sheffield Road Whittington Moor Derbyshire S41 8LF for Peppermint Grove

 

CHE/19/00355/NMA

Non material amendment to retain some of the existing load bearing masonry, bi-fold doors to incorporate fixed glazing and pedestrian door of application of CHE/16/00818/FUL (Proposed restaurant on the building 3rd floor (opening times in accordance with existing licence).  Alteration and widening of ground floor opening to accommodate new bi-fold doors.  Installation of retractable awning canopy to building entrance (minimum 2.3m high) at The Loft 21 Holywell Street Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 7SA for G Livoti

 

CHE/19/00369/ADV

Installation of full width fascia signage with face and halo illuminated letters.  Installation of 2no. internally illuminated   projecting signs, face and halo illuminated ATM tablet, entrance illuminated accent strip and vinyl sign and window graphics (revised drawings received 20.08.2019, 11.09.2019 and 20.09.2019) at 2 Stephenson Place and 1 Cavendish Street Chesterfield S40 1XP for The Royal Bank of Scotland

 

CHE/19/00371/LBC

Removal of existing external ATM and signage, removal of 3 sections of high level fascia and logo signage, removal of existing projecting sign.  Removal of illuminated window posters. Installation of new external ATM (to adapted aperture) with internally illuminated tablet.  Installation of new fascia signage with internally illuminated letters and logo. Installation of 2 internally illuminated projecting signs. Installation of new entrance vinyl signage and illuminated accent strip.  Installation of new vinyl graphic to selected windows. Internal: Removal of existing cashier counter and associated partitions to front of Banking Hall and installation of part height automation wall with automation items.  Boarding up 1no. existing cashier counter position to back of Banking Hall and installation of new recessed digital screen. General refurbishment and installation of new furniture and lighting to match existing (revised drawings received 20.08.2019, 11.09.2019 and 20.09.2019) at 2 Stephenson Place and 1 Cavendish Street Chesterfield S40 1XP for The Royal Bank of Scotland

 

CHE/19/00373/MA

Material  ...  view the full minutes text for item 60.

61.

Applications to Fell or Prune Trees (P620D) pdf icon PDF 43 KB

Additional documents:

Minutes:

*The Development Management and Conservation Manager reported that pursuant to the powers delegated to him he had determined the under-mentioned applications in respect of the felling and pruning of trees:-

 

CHE/19/00420/TPO

 

Consent is refused to the pruning of one Oak tree reference T2 on the Order map for Mrs Riley of 10 Dorothy Vale, Ashgate.

 

Consent is granted to the crown lifting of the tree by 4 metres and the crown thinning by 25%.

 

CHE/19/00454/TPO

 

Consent is granted to the pruning of one Oak tree reference T1 on the Order map for Mrs Marper of 14 Dorothy Vale, Ashgate.

 

CHE/19/00463/TPO

 

Consent is refused to the crown reduction of two Lawson Cypress trees reference T9 &T10 on the Order map for Mrs Wagstaffe of 11 Westfield Close, Brampton.

 

CHE/19/00522/TPO

 

Consent is granted to the coppicing of 5 Willow trees within W1 on the Order map for Miss Ward on land adjacent to 7 Marine Drive, Piccadilly.

 

CHE/19/00480/TPO

 

Consent is refused to the felling of two Ash trees and the crown reduction of four Ash trees within G1 on the Order map for Mr Walters of Oldfield Farm, Wetlands Lane, Brimington.

 

Consent is granted to the reduction of branches around the telephone wires and the removal of major dead wood.

 

CHE/19/00499/TPO

 

Consent is granted to the pruning of one Poplar tree reference T1 on the Order map for Gary McCarthy on behalf of Chesterfield Borough Council on land to the rear of 36 Bellhouse Lane, Lowgates.

 

CHE/19/00516/TPO

 

Consent is granted to the pruning of one Oak tree reference T2 on the Order map for Ted Firth on behalf of Chesterfield Borough Council at 21 Spring Wood Close, Dunston.

 

CHE/19/00500/TPO

 

Consent is granted to the pruning of three Ash trees reference T13, T14 and T15 on the Order map for Gary McCarthy on behalf of Chesterfield Borough Council at Staveley War Memorial Gardens.

 

CHE/19/00488/TPO

 

Consent is granted to the felling of two Yew trees and the pruning of two Yew trees within G2 on the Order map for Mr Kirby of 96 Mansfield Road, Hasland.

 

CHE/19/00484/TPO

 

Consent is granted to the pruning of 3 tree reference T11, T12 and T13 Ash on the Order Map and which are situated to the rear of 42 The Meadows and 2 Foxbrook Close, Ashgate for Taylor Wimpey Yorkshire.

 

62.

Appeals Report (P000) pdf icon PDF 45 KB

Additional documents:

Minutes:

The Development Management and Conservation Manager reported on the current position in respect of appeals which had been received.

 

*RESOLVED -

 

That the report be noted.

63.

Enforcement Report (P410) pdf icon PDF 89 KB

Minutes:

The Local Government and Regulatory Law Manager and the Development Management and Conservation Manager submitted a joint report on the current position regarding enforcement action which had been authorised by the Council.

 

*RESOLVED -

 

That the report be noted.