Agenda item

(a)   Approvals

CHE/19/00045/RET

Retrospective consent for the retention of a rear single storey extension at 184 Peveril Road Newbold S41 8SH for Mr Dave McElvaney

CHE/19/00140/FUL

Demolition of existing workshop building and erection of a cattery building (with separate isolation building to the front) and creation of 4 parking spaces to the front - revised plans received 19 September 2019 at 36 Hady Lane Hady Derbyshire S41 0DF for Mrs Lisa Higginbottom

CHE/19/00292/FUL

Conversion of triple garage to 2 bedroom bungalow (amended Plans received on 11.09.2019 and structural report received 11.11.2019) at Plover Hill Farm Wetlands Lane Brimington Derbyshire S43 1QG for Mr Lee Jenkins

CHE/19/00368/FUL

Erection of 7 industrial units for B2 use (industrial) - Sequential Test received 27/08/2019; Mining Report received 29/09/2019; Revised drawings received 30/09/2019; Drainage info received 16/10/2019, and Flood-Risk Assessment received 17/10/2019 at Warehouse adj to Unit 17 Whitting Valley Road Old Whittington for A and J Properties Ltd

CHE/19/00435/COU

Use of additional room in property for dog day care business (additional drawings provided detailing internal layout of building 15.10.2019) at The Chantry 39 High Street Staveley Derbyshire for Mrs Nadia Rogers

CHE/19/00506/FUL

Re-submission of application CHE/14/00818/FUL - addition of an 8.64m 3.27m Portacabin to be attached to the front of the existing building for extra office space for new employees at Speeds Plastics Wheatbridge Road Chesterfield S40 2AB for Speed Plastics Ltd

CHE/19/00541/FUL

Installation of a 1,580sqm mezzanine at Spire Walk Business Park, Unit 2 Spire Walk Chesterfield S40 2WG for Dunelm (Soft Furnishings) Ltd

CHE/19/00542/REM1

Variation of condition 15 of CHE/11/00339/REM1) to amend the quantum of approved use/floorspace restrictions (as set out in detail in the planning application submission) at Spire Walk Business Park, Unit 2 Spire Walk Chesterfield S40 2WG for Dunelm (Soft Furnishings) Ltd

CHE/19/00553/RET

Continued siting of 5 metal clad storage units, and retention of palisade fencing and gates (to replace existing) at Chiltern Glass Fibre Barker Lane                                   Chesterfield Derbyshire for Mr Darren Kuchta

CHE/19/00557/FUL

Re-submission of CHE/19 00298/FUL - First floor extension to the rear elevation at 189 Station Road Brimington S43 1LL for Mrs Laura Jenkins

CHE/19/00571/FUL

Proposed side extension at 6 Brincliffe Close Walton Derbyshire S40 3DU for Mr and Mrs Shepley

CHE/19/00574/FUL

External and site layout alterations consisting of external escape staircase, replacement of 2 trolley bays with covered trolley bay and the loss of two existing parking spaces to existing retail unit (Class A1) - amended plan received 18/11/2019 at Wheatbridge Retail Park, Wickes Building Supplies Ltd Wheatbridge Road Chesterfield                                S40 2AB for Wickes Building Supplies Limited

CHE/19/00575/FUL

Installation of a Class A1 mezzanine floor at Wheatbridge Retail Park, Wickes Building Supplies Ltd Wheatbridge Road Chesterfield S40 2AB for Wickes Building Supplies

CHE/19/00580/FUL

Demolition of existing single storey rear extension and change of use from offices (Class B1) into 2 residential dwellings (Class C3) (with revised drawings submitted 14.11.19) at 160-162 Derby Road Chesterfield S40 2EW for W.G Pollard Ltd

CHE/19/00581/FUL

Two storey side extension and single storey rear extensions including rebuilding of existing garage at 54 Morris Avenue Newbold Chesterfield S41 7BA for Mrs Janice Hoskin

CHE/19/00585/RET

Erection of a 2 metre high boundary fence of concrete posts and wooden panels at 8 Thorndon Way Walton Chesterfield S40 3DW for Mr Bryn Holmes

CHE/19/00596/FUL

Three storey rear extension and new external stairs from rear balcony at 66 Langer Lane Birdholme Derbyshire S40 2JG for Mrs Dawn Growcott

CHE/19/00605/FUL

Two storey front extension at 756 Chatsworth Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 3PN for Mr Mark Redford

CHE/19/00608/FUL

Single-storey glass room to the rear elevation of the property at 228 Manor Road Brimington Chesterfield S43 1NW for Mr Jones

CHE/19/00609/FUL

Extension for warehousing and ancillary offices and amenities at Peak Pipe Systems Smeckley Wood Close Chesterfield Trading Estate Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 9PZ for Bridgstock Ltd

CHE/19/00615/FUL

Demolition of existing extension to front of property and construction of new replacement extension at 706 Chatsworth Road Chesterfield S40 3PB for Mr and Mrs Mansell

CHE/19/00618/FUL

Single storey front extension (parking plan received 05.11.2019, additional car hardstanding drawing received 27.11.2019) at 230 Walton Road Walton S40 3BS for Mr Robert Colby

CHE/19/00623/TPO

T1 Lime - crown lift and crown clean to remove dead material.  T2 Hawthorne - crown clean to remove dead material.  Sweet Chestnut - remove deadwood and low level branch to the north of the stem at 93 High Street Old Whittington S41 9LB for Mrs Susan Smith

CHE/19/00630/FUL

Two storey side extension with single storey rear extension.  Revised drawing received 18.11.2019 at 7 Norwood Close Hasland Chesterfield S41 0NL for Mr and Mrs Shaw

CHE/19/00632/FUL

Single storey side extension at 1 Ardsley Road Ashgate Chesterfield S40 4DG for B and V Burborough

CHE/19/00637/TPO

Pruning of oak tree at 7 Bunting Close Walton                                     Derbyshire S42 7NU for Dr Anura Piyadigamage

CHE/19/00639/NMA

Non Material amendment to CHE/18/00619/FUL (Installation of a reserve power plant capacity following demolition of existing building) to allow the developers to re-arrange the structures within the power plant to facilitate greater efficiency at Units 1 - 3 Sheepbridge Lane Sheepbridge Derbyshire S41 9RX for EcoDev Group

CHE/19/00656/NMA

Non material amendment to CHE/19/00239/FUL (Residential development comprising the erection of  21 two, three and 4 bedroomed dwellings accessed by a new estate road from Cheedale Avenue, with associated footpaths and parking court/parking spaces, boundary walls and fences, retaining walls and area for public art) to allow for minor roof pitch modifications and window configuration  to 'Cardinham', Thetford and Rockingham house types at former Brockwell Court Brockwell Lane Brockwell Chesterfield S40 4PJ for Chesterfield Borough Council

CHE/19/00657/TPO

T1 Beech - to be felled and replaced with an oak; and T2 Oak - to be pruned and reshaped at highway verge adj 5 Ashleigh Close Old Whittington Derbyshire S41 9NA for Derbyshire County Council

CHE/19/00673/TPO

x2 Large Sycamores located in adjacent property - crown lift to approx 5m to clear buildings, crown thin approx 15/20% at Amies Plastics Quarry Lane Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 3AT for Amies Plastics

CHE/19/00689/TPO

Crown clean and crown lift to approx. 3m of oak (T1) and crown clean and crown lift to approx 2-3m to give clearance from house of oak (T2) at 17 Wessington Drive Staveley Derbyshire S43 3NX for Clarion Housing

CHE/19/00694/NMA

Non material amendment to CHE/18/00477/ful (Mixed use B1, B2, and B8 Units with car parking) for the addition of one window to Unit 4 at Unit 1 Turnoaks Industrial Estate Turnoaks Lane Birdholme Derbyshire S40 2HA for Mr Whittaker

CHE/19/00703/TPO

Oak Tree TPO 99 - lift crown to clear lower branches over the driveway, footpath and highway.  Clear crown to remove any dead wood.  Prune back away from the property and telephone wires at 9 Grasmere Close Newbold Derbyshire S41 8EG for Mrs Heather Volli

CHE/19/00705/TPO

T1 - Lime - crown lift to give 3m clearance from ground, and crown thin by approx. 30%. Tree has Ganoderma at base, but client does not want to lose the tree, so is going to monitor over the next few years at 658 Chatsworth Road Chesterfield S40 3NU for Richard Neep

CHE/19/00708/CA

Crown lift and crown thin willow tree to allow access to public footpath, crown reduce and general pruning of apple tree, removal of conifer, crown reduce holly trees (4 and 5) to height of hedge, crown reduce tree (6) to hedge height, reduce height of privet hedge at Manor Hall Farm 102 Church Street North Old Whittington Derbyshire S41 9QP for Mr and Mrs Walters        

CHE/19/00710/TPO

Cedar and copper beech to be felled at The Homestead 323 Ashgate Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 4DB for Mr Norman Tate

CHE/19/00086/FUL

Two storey extensions to side and rear of house to create larger bedrooms, shower room and garden room extension - revised plan received 27 November 2019 at 77 Brushfield Road Holme Hall Chesterfield S40 4XF for Mr K More

CHE/19/00154/RET

Retrospective consent for change of use of car showroom and workshop (sui generis) to a tyre garage (sui generis) with office at the rear.  Front office demolished and moved to the rear with new shutters to the front at rear of 34 Chatsworth Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 2AQ for 24 Tyres

CHE/19/00161/FUL

Proposed single storey bowls pavilion at Recreation Ground Stand Road Newbold for Chesterfield Borough Council

CHE/19/00472/COU

Change of use of land to permanent caravan storage at Sheepbridge Caravan Storage at land between River Drone and River Whitting Sheepbridge Lane Sheepbridge for Mrs Jennifer Rodgers

CHE/19/00507/FUL 

Ground floor extension to front of property.  Revised plans received 22 October 2019 at 19 Cromdale Avenue New Whittington S43 2DH for Mrs Amanda Gandee

CHE/19/00538/FUL

Single storey side and rear extension at 120 Mansfield Road Hasland S41 0JQ for Mr T Hayden

CHE/19/00556/FUL

Extension to existing double garage to provide ancillary accommodation at 2 The Hazelmeres Hazel Drive Walton S40 3FE for Mr Guy Rosewarne

CHE/19/00609/FUL

Extension for warehousing and ancillary offices and amenities at Peak Pipe Systems Smeckley Wood Close Trading Estate Chesterfield S41 9PZ for Bridgstock Ltd

CHE/19/00613/LBC

Proposed works to listed building including repair/replacement roof finish, works to chimney and works to guttering at Royal Oak 1 The Shambles Chesterfield S40 1PX for EI Group PLC

CHE/19/00631/FUL

Two storey rear extension.  Revised drawings received 8.11.2019 at 26 Westbrook Drive Chesterfield S40 3PQ for Mr and Mrs Richards

CHE/19/00645/FUL

Two storey rear extension to dwelling at 1 Manknell Road Whittington Moor S41 8LZ for Mr G Tyson

CHE/19/00646/COU

Change of use from offices to community centre (Use Class A2 Financial and professional services to D1 Non-residential institutions) at 10A Marsden Street Chesterfield S40 1JY for Mr Mahroof Saddique

CHE/19/00650/TPO

Crown reduction and at the back of 27 Newbold Road at Deen and Da Awah Centre 29 Newbold Road Newbold S41 7PG for Mrs Sharon Whelan

CHE/19/00652/FUL

Single storey extension replacing existing conservatory at 8 Well Spring Close Brimington Chesterfield S43 1QX for Mr and Mrs Robert Elshaw

CHE/19/00659/FUL

Two storey side extension and single storey rear extension at 7 Mansfeldt Crescent Newbold S41 7BP for Mr S Barton

CHE/19/00662/FUL

Front extension to hallway and creation of additional hardstanding at 122 Mansfield Road Hasland S41 0JQ for Mr and Mrs M Oades

CHE/19/00679/REM1 

Removal of condition 4 of CHE/12/00336/FUL (relating to the occupation of a garage/elderly persons ancillary accommodation) to allow temporary occupation, whilst the host dwelling is re-built at 23 Bridle Road Woodthorpe Chesterfield S43 3BY for Mr S Weatherall

CHE/19/00680/REM1 

Variation of condition 2 of CHE/17/00855/FUL (Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of replacement house) to allow insertion of additional windows and roof lights at 23 Bridle Road Woodthorpe S43 3BY for Mr S Weatherall

CHE/19/00692/TPO

Crown thinning and removal of one lower limb lifting back to 4.5m to retain tree health of oak tree at 46 Bentham Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 4EZ for Mr Christopher Drury

CHE/19/00697/TPO 

Two Sycamore trees to be removed and two to be crown lifted and thinned at land formerly known as Brookside Farm Chesterfield Road Brimington for Mr Simon Parker

CHE/19/00751/TPO

T4 - Sycamore tree - 50% crown reduction in height and crown lift (2 lower branches). To increase lighting and drainage to neighbouring gardens at 32 Hillside Drive Walton S40 2DB for Mr Richard Hawksworth

CHE/19/00755/CA

T7 - Noble Fir- Remove. This tree is a constraint to development and has short term potential only. G1 - A group of self-set ash and sycamore - Prune back to boundary. G2 - A collection of conifers forming a low-level landscape feature - Remove to allow room for development. To be replaced with native shrubs during landscaping at 97 High Street Old Whittington S41 9LB for Mrs Susan Smith

CHE/19/00757/NMA 

Non material amendment to CHE/18/00805/REM (Reserved Matters submission for the erection of 200 dwellings and associated landscaping) to alter garages to plots 145 and 146 and amendments to and re-naming of former house types B and D at land to the west of Dunston Lane Newbold for William Davis Limited

CHE/19/00767/NMA

Non material amendment to CHE/19/00574/FUL (External and site layout alterations consisting of external escape staircase, replacement of 2 trolley bays with covered trolley bay and the loss of two existing parking spaces  to existing retail unit (Class A1)) to allow for a re-figured car parking layout at Wickes Building Supplies Ltd Wheatbridge Retail Park Wheatbridge Road Chesterfield S40 2AB for Wickes Building Supplies Limited

(b)   Refusals

CHE/19/00389/COU

Re-submission of CHE/19/00262/COU - Change of use from warehousing (B8) to Assembly and Leisure (D2) at Unit 18 Broombank Park Chesterfield Trading Estate Chesterfield for The Combat Academy (Chesterfield) Ltd

CHE/19/00523/FUL

Erection of detached bungalow at land to the rear of 175 Station Road Brimington Derbyshire for Ms Angerina Price

CHE/19/00534/RET

Retrospective application for existing children’s play house with proposed wooden boarding and narrow piece of obscure laminated glass at 94 Chester Street Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 1DN for Mr Paul Servante

CHE/19/00633/TPO

Pines (TG1) - fell close to ground level 02/12/2019 Pine (T1) T2 T3 - fell close to ground level Pine (T2) - fell close to ground level Pine (T3) - fell close to ground level

1. The above tree works are proposed as a remedy to the differential foundation movement at the insured property and to ensure the long-term stability of the building.

2. The above tree works are proposed to limit the extent and need for expensive and disruptive engineering repair works at the insured property. In this instance the estimated repair costs are likely to vary between £25,000 and £75,000, depending upon whether the tree/s can be removed or must remain. 

3. The above tree works are proposed to limit the duration of any claim period and therefore allow the landowner their right to the peaceful enjoyment of their property.

4. It is the case that an alternative to felling such as pruning or significant 'pollarding' of the tree would not provide a reliable or sustainable remedy to the subsidence in this case.  We do not consider that any other potential means of mitigation, including root barriers, would be effective or appropriate in the circumstances.

5. We are satisfied that the evidence obtained following completion of our Arboricultural Implication Assessment report completed 18th July 2019, clearly links the Pine trees as the cause of damage to the risk address.

6. Insurers understanding the requirement to offer replacement planting in the event consent to fell is granted.

at 406 Old Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 3QF for Property Risk Inspection

CHE/19/00622/FUL

Two storey rear and side extension at 112 Burnbridge Road Old Whittington Derbyshire for Mr Robert Allen

(c)  Discharge of Planning Condition

CHE/19/00568/DOC

Discharge of condition 5 (tree protection), condition 7 (lighting), condition 8 (ecology), condition 9 (tree planting), condition 10 (ground investigation) of CHE/18/00009/REM - Reserved matters application for 1 dwelling - related to CHE/15/00594/OUT Outline application  for residential development of up to 10 dwellings at land surrounding 146 to 152 Hady Lane Hady Lane Hady for Mrs Natalie Harbour

CHE/19/00587/DOC

Discharge of conditions 3 (surface water), 4 (surface water drainage), 5 (light glare to motorists), 8 (revised site layout) and 11 (external lighting) of CHE/19/207/FUL - New HGV testing station and ancillary offices at Plot 5                                     Markham Lane Duckmanton Derbyshire for Transcare Properties Ltd

CHE/19/00591/DOC

Discharge of condition 10 (AMS and Tree Protection Plan) and condition 15 (Training and Employment) of CHE/19/00373/MA - Extension of 1068sqm (GEA) to an existing industrial warehouse including associated proposed castings yard, car parking and landscaping. Upgrade to the existing external walls and new roof along with internal energy efficiency upgrade at Precision Products Ltd Cobnar Wood Close Chesterfield Trading Estate Chesterfield S41 9RQ for Precision Products Ltd                             

CHE/19/00599/DOC

Discharge of condition 3 (Site Investigation) of CHE/18/00826/FUL - Erection of portal framed warehouse/showroom with associated parking and yard at GKN Sheepbridge Stokes Ltd Sheepbridge Lane Sheepbridge S41 9QD for T G Beighton

CHE/19/00604/DOC

Discharge of condition 4 re drainage re CHE/19/00457/FUL - Removal of garden wall to create hard standing driveway at 599 Chatsworth Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 3JY for Mr S Humphreys

CHE/19/00612/DOC

Discharge of condition 13 (materials) of CHE/18/00605/FUL - Refurbish and extend existing property and change use to residential care home facility and demolition of existing ancillary building to the rear and erection of three storey building to create assisted living facility at 6 Ashgate Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 4AA for Aspire Health and Care

CHE/19/00628/DOC

Discharge of condition 4 (Employment and Training Scheme), condition 6 (Site Set up and Traffic Plan) condition 9 (Section 38 layout), condition 9 (Highway Details), condition 9 (Kerb Layout), conditions 9 and 24 (Manhole Schedule, Drainage simulation results, Drainage Strategy Plan, Drainage Catchment, Site Levels, S104 Layouts, Road and sewer sections and Manhole Details), condition 13 (Street Maintenance), condition 15 (Phase II Site Investigation Report) condition 16 (Materials), condition 19 (Site Layout), condition 19 (Bin Store and boundary treatments) of CHE/19/00239/FUL - Res development- the erection of 21 dwellings, new estate road with associated footpaths and parking court/parking spaces, boundary walls and fences, retaining walls and area for public art at former Brockwell Court Brockwell Lane Chesterfield

CHE/19/00682/DOC

Discharge of condition 9 (remediation method statement) of CHE/18/00826/FUL - Erection of portal framed warehouse/showroom with associated parking and yard at GKN Sheepbridge Stokes Ltd Sheepbridge Lane Sheepbridge Derbyshire S41 9QD for T G Beighton Limited

CHE/19/00701/DOC

Discharge of conditions 4 and 5 in relation to planning application no CHE/16/00333/FUL at 145 Burnbridge Road Old Whittington Derbyshire S41 9LT for Chris Johnson

CHE/19/00706/DOC

Discharge of condition 3 (tree protection measures) of CHE/19/00174/FUL - Erection of single storey rear extension at 16 Booker Close Inkersall Chesterfield S43 3WA for Samantha Townsend

CHE/19/00589/DOC

Discharge of planning conditions 6 (Surface Water) and 7 (Surface Water - Building Regs) of CHE/15/00344/OUT - Outline application for residential development at land to the rear of 292 Manor Road Brimington Chesterfield S43 1NX for Arncliffe Homes Ltd

CHE/19/00614/DOC

Discharge of conditions 5 (materials), 9  (surface water), 13 (site investigation) and 14 (mining) of CHE/18/00012/OUT  - (Outline application for redevelopment of the existing site for residential use) and condition 7 (materials) of CHE/18/00867/REM - Reserved matters for application CHE/18/00012/OUT (Outline application for one residential unit) at land at Middlecroft Road Staveley for TGN Construction Ltd

CHE/19/00643/DOC

Discharge of conditions 4, 5, 6, 7 and 24 (Drainage simulation results, Catchment Area Plan, Drainage Layout  Plan and Site Levels Plan), condition 8 (Coal Mining Risk Assessment), condition 9 (Site Investigation), condition 10 (CEMP), condition 11 (Planting scheme and LEMP), condition 13 (TMP), condition 16 (S38 Coloured Layout, Highway Construction  details, Section 278 Plan , Private surfacing layout), condition 23 (Site waste management Plan, Waste Audit), condition 26 (Management company details), condition 27 (Employment and Training details), condition 30 (materials schedule), condition 31 (DWT recommendations, Tree contaminants Plan - Plot 1,  Tree Protection Plan  Plot 1,  AMS,  AIA) of CHE/15/00835/OUT - residential development at development land west of Loundsley Green Road Loundsley Green Chesterfield for Starfish Commercial

CHE/19/00681/DOC

Discharge of condition11 (Ecology Enhancement scheme) of CHE/18/00768/REM - residential development of 33 dwellings at land to south of Poplar Farm Rectory Road Duckmanton for Trowbridge

(d)  Prior notification approval not required

CHE/19/00629/TPD

Single storey rear extension at 72 Brearley Avenue New Whittington Derbyshire S43 2DY for Mr S Syddall

CHE/19/00660/TPD

Single storey rear extension at 191 Ashgate Road                                    Ashgate Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 4AP for Ms Carolyn Le Lievre

CHE/19/00664/TPD

Extension to dwelling at 55 Hawksley Avenue                                     Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 4TJ for Mrs Margaret Chapman

CHE/19/00693/TPD

Demolition of external toilet/washroom and garden store and replacing with single storey rear extension at 65 Rutland Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 1ND for Mr M Koniarski

(e)  CLOPUD Granted

CHE/19/00712/CLO

Demolition of existing carport and erection of single storey side extension at 16 Ashgate Valley Road Chesterfield S40 4AX for Mr Bilby               

(f)  Split decision with conditions

CHE/19/00667/TPO

Trees require responsible management to ensure ongoing health and prevent nuisance at 10 Sherbourne Avenue Newbold Derbyshire S41 8TL for Mr Michael Nind

CHE/19/00711/TPO

Two trees, raise canopy to 5m, reduce height by 2m, at 1 The Dell Ashgate Chesterfield S40 4DL for Mrs Handley