Agenda item

(a)   Approvals

CHE/20/00696/FUL

Re-submission of CHE/19/00120/FUL - Increase window size to the shop front and form a new window opening to the eastern elevation (revised drawings received 27.05.2021) at Pinewood Property Lettings Ltd 33 Holywell Street Chesterfield S41 7SA for Pinewood Properties

CHE/20/00772/FUL

Conversion of offices above retail units to form 7 residential apartments, 1 office unit and the amendment/replacement of existing rear windows.  Revised drawings received 15.01.2021, 18.02.2021 and 11.05.21. (Description revised 13/05/21 from 9 units) at 9 - 21 Stephenson Place Chesterfield S40 1XL for Sycamore Estates

CHE/20/00783/FUL

Two storey rear extension and raised decking (Revised drawing received 24.06.2021) at 18 Orchards Way Walton Derbyshire S40 3BZ for Mr C Hoyland     

CHE/20/00859/ADV

Freestanding billboard to provide directions to the associated Lidl store.  Revised drawings received 11.03.2021and 12.05.21 at Lidl Sheffield Road Whittington Moor Chesterfield S41 8LX for Lidl UK GmbH              

CHE/21/00042/COU

Change of use from retail to drinking establishment and refurbishment of front of property with tiling at 10 Station Road Whittington Moor Chesterfield S41 9AQ for Mr John Norton

CHE/21/00088/TPO

T104 - T105 Beech  - Crown reduce and fell T88 Sweet Gum. - Revised application at The Fold 4 Somersall Willows Chesterfield S40 3SR for Mr Peter Watmore

CHE/21/00123/COU

Change of use from former shop to sui generis tattoo studio at 32A Chesterfield Road Staveley Derbyshire S43 3QF for Ms Alison Riley          

CHE/21/00136/REM

Variation of conditions 13 (landscaping) and 14 (planting schedule) of CHE/19/00735/FUL - demolition of existing garages and erection of 6 self-contained single storey complex behavioural bungalows and 6 self-contained assisted living apartments over 2 storeys and new tarmac through road linking Bank Street and Chester Street. (revised drawing received 18/05/21) at Garage Sites Bank Street Chesterfield S40 1BH for Chesterfield SSL Ltd

CHE/21/00228/FUL

Proposed extension to front of house to create larger family/dining room and new access arrangement - Revised drawing received 19/05/2021 at 15 Tunstall Way Walton Derbyshire S40 2RH for Mr N Bissett

CHE/21/00240/FUL

Side extension at 4 Nevis Close Loundsley Green Chesterfield S40 4NS for Mr and Mrs Debell

CHE/21/00242/FUL

Ground floor extension to side elevation and hipped roof to gable at first floor at 59 Alexandra Road East Chesterfield S41 0HF for Mr Mark Simpson

CHE/21/00267/FUL

First floor extension to the front elevation at 19 Cromford Drive Staveley Derbyshire S43 3TB for Mr Glen Pashley

CHE/21/00270/FUL

Two storey front extension, single storey side extension and front bay window and canopy at 6 Beacon Hill Way Hasland Chesterfield S41 0AF for Mr Lambert

CHE/21/00271/FUL

Two storey extension at 113 The Green Hasland S41 0JT for Mr Mike Riley

CHE/21/00279/FUL

Flat roofed porch to front of house with balcony over at 9 Waltham Croft Hasland Derbyshire S41 0UZ for Catherine Copley

CHE/21/00280/FUL

Proposed side and rear extension at Davenport 592 Chatsworth Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 3JX for Ms Donna Hammond

CHE/21/00283/FUL

First floor side extension at 9 Greengate Close Chesterfield S40 3SJ for Mr Ian Davidson

CHE/21/00285/RET

Retention of wall and gateway at Mayfields Hady Lane Hady Derbyshire S41 0DE for Mr J Cash

CHE/21/00289/NMA

Non-material amendment to CHE/19/00596/FUL (Three storey rear extension and new external stairs from rear balcony) to amend design of balcony and alterations to external staircase to spiral at 66 Langer Lane Birdholme Derbyshire S40 2JG for Mrs Dawn Growcott                

CHE/21/00293/COU

Change of use of ground floor retail premises to dog grooming salon at 401A Sheffield Road Whittington Moor Derbyshire S41 8LS for Mrs Caroline Miles

CHE/21/00295/FUL

Conversion of existing garage to form extended kitchen (amended plan received 14.06.2021) at 25 Manor House Court Stonegravels Chesterfield S41 7GY for Daniella Else

CHE/21/00296/FUL

First floor extension above garage at front and rear of property at 18 Tollbridge Road Woodthorpe S43 3BL for Mr Daniel Saunby

CHE/21/00301/FUL

Conversion of existing garage to two bed bungalow ancillary to primary accommodation of 61 Brockwell Lane for dependant relative at 61 Brockwell Lane Brockwell Chesterfield S40 4ED for Mr Desmond Spencer

CHE/21/00302/FUL

Minor external alteration works comprising part build-up of external door opening to existing store at rear and installation of new PVCU casement window (amended drawings received 17.06.2021) at Britannia Inn 56 Old Hall Road Chesterfield S40 1HD for Stonegate Group

CHE/21/00304/FUL

Proposed single storey front extension at 31 Hill View Road Brimington S43 1JW for Mr and Mrs Turner

CHE/21/00319/FUL

Removal of existing conservatory and construction of new single storey extension at 1 Wain Avenue Chesterfield S41 0FD for Mrs J Winfrow

CHE/21/00327/FUL

Proposed front extension at 3 Barley Lane Holme Hall Chesterfield S42 7JA for Yumer Mastev

CHE/21/00332/FUL

Removal of existing conservatory to the rear and construction of single storey kitchen/dining extension at 176 Old Hall Road Chesterfield S40 1HQ for Ms N Betts

CHE/21/00334/FUL

Single storey rear extension at 55 Chantrey Avenue Newbold Derbyshire S41 7DP for Mr Mark Pugh

CHE/21/00341/FUL

Proposed rear extension and alterations to front elevation at 32 Holmebank West Brockwell Chesterfield S40 4AS for Mr and Mrs Krousti

CHE/21/00384/TPO

Crown lift and thin to T49 at 40 Netherleigh Road Ashgate Chesterfield S40 3QJ for Mr Mark Wilson

CHE/21/00386/CA

Crown lift to between 3 and 4 metres pruning back to suitable growth parts of 2 flowering cherries, remove laurel to ground level, remove 40-50% of crown of holly to reduce height, remove self-seeded willow in the front garden at 16 Church Street North Old Whittington Derbyshire S41 9QW for Ms Naomi Redhouse

CHE/21/00412/CA

6 large mix-species trees to have 30% crown reductions of the full crown though so they're not imbalanced and clear way (pictures attached) at 49 Victoria Street Chesterfield S41 7LQ for The Guinness Partnership

CHE/21/00415/TPO

Felling of two trees x1 Cherry and x1 Sycamore within G2 of Tree Preservation Order 4901.37 at 1 Eyre Gardens Highfield Road Newbold S41 7EL for The Guinness Partnership

CHE/21/00428/TPO

Crown reduce canopy by 4m and remove all major dead wood that may present a hazard to neighbouring properties. Prune back to suitable growing points to ensure the tree retains a balanced crown structure at 4 Orwins Close Newbold Road Newbold S41 8AQ for Mr Gary McCarthy

CHE/21/00441/TPO

Deadwood Oak (T1), fell Larch (T2-T5) and replant alder or willow at 19A Somersall Lane Somersall Derbyshire S40 3LA for Mr David Lyon

CHE/21/00459/TPO

Crown reduce by 3m and remove epicormic growth at 136 Kirkstone Road Newbold S41 8HF for Mr Gary McCarthy

CHE/21/00463/TPO

T1 Ash - The tree has already 50% Ash die back and needs to be felled at Masonic Hall 72 Saltergate Chesterfield S40 1JR for Chesterfield Masonic Hall

CHE/21/00474/CA

Pruning of Himalayan birch to attain a clearance of 1m from structure at Avenue House Surgery 109 Saltergate Chesterfield S40 1LE for Inspire Health

CHE/21/00486/TPO

Remove dead wood - T4 Ash at Eyre Chapel Newbold Village Newbold Road Derbyshire S41 8RJ for Derbyshire County Council

CHE/21/00487/TPO

Fell T34 Beech at Sonoco Consumer Products Portland Works Goyt Side Road Chesterfield S40 2PH for Derbyshire County Council

CHE/21/00491/TPO

Mixed deciduous trees adjoining footpath as indicated on attached sketch plan. Cut back from the footpath and crown raise lower branches to a height of 2.5m to permit access for pedestrians at 2 Bar Croft Newbold S40 4YG for Mr Gary McCarthy

(b)   Refusal

CHE/20/00837/NMA

Non-material amendment to the planning conditions In relation to CHE/16/00835/FUL. Condition numbers 08,09,11,16, relevant to phase 1 - Conversion/extension of the existing building - The Elm Tree Inn. Relevant condition numbers 03,06,07,12,13,15,17 and 18 to phase 2 New build 3 storey block to the rear and 2 storey building to the LHS of the Elm Tree incl associated hard and soft landscaping at The Elm Tree Inn High Street Staveley Derbyshire S43 3UU for Vanessa Zheng

CHE/21/00095/FUL

Proposed two storey rear extension at 126 Highfield Road Newbold Derbyshire S41 7HT for Mr Anthony Payne

CHE/21/00141/FUL

Erection of a two storey rear extension with a flat roof and a two storey side extension for a garage with room above. (Description amended 04/05/21) at 257 Hasland Road Hasland S41 0AA for Mr Liam Gavan

CHE/21/00306/CLO

New single storey side extension as per submitted drawing - 2021:011 - 02 at 26 Linden Drive Hasland S41 0NQ for Mr Sam Gregory

CHE/21/00321/CLO

Erection of single storey rear extension with rooflights at 50 Langhurst Road Brockwell Chesterfield S40 4BD for Debra Atkinson

CHE/21/00336/TPO

T5 - Sycamore - Remove as close to ground level as possible. (Tree is on land owned by Chesterfield Borough Council adjacent to 120 The Green). 

The tree works are proposed to stop the influence of the tree(s) on the soil below building foundation level and provide long term stability.

Estimated costs of repair to the building are £30,000.00, if the influence of the tree(s) remain and £17, 377.00 if the proposed tree works are allowed to proceed. Granting permission will limit these costs. In the event of a refusal we, or our clients, will seek to secure compensation for the additional costs incurred through Section 202(e).  Should the tree/s remain the total cost of repairs will be the Superstructural repairs + Alternative method of repairs = £47,377.00.

It is the expert opinion of both the case engineer and arboriculturist that on the balance of probabilities the supporting information demonstrates the influence of the tree(s).

Note: Further monitoring results may be submitted if these become available during the course of this application.

At 120 The Green Hasland Derbyshire S41 0JU for Environmental Services

(c)  Discharge of Planning Condition

CHE/20/00840/DOC

Discharge of conditions 4 (materials), 7 (owl/kestrel box), 8 (hard and soft landscaping) and 9 (site investigation) of CHE/19/00149/FUL - Refurbishment of existing unit and proposed new warehouse at Denka UK Ltd Broombank Road Chesterfield Trading Estate Chesterfield S41 9QJ for Denka UK Ltd

CHE/21/00206/DOC

Discharge of condition 4 of CHE/20/00434/FUL at 56 Vincent Crescent Chesterfield S40 3NP for Mr and Mrs Lilley

CHE/21/00247/DOC

Discharge of planning conditions 5 (materials), 6 (hard and soft landscaping), 7 (planting), 11 (site traffic management) and 12 (car parking) of CHE/20/00619/FUL - Erection of a 4 bed dwelling at 37 Whittington Hill Old Whittington Derbyshire S41 9HJ for Mr Andrew Bayliss

CHE/21/00405/DOC

Discharge of condition 4 (Devpt framework masterplan) of CHE/19/00131/OUT - Outline planning permission for up to 400 dwellings and provision of an area of public open space, with associated landscaping and access from Inkersall Road and Inkersall Green Road at land to west of Inkersall Road Staveley Derbyshire for Barratt Homes

CHE/21/00417/DOC

Discharge of conditions 3, 6 and 7 for planning application reference CHE/17/00868/FUL at 69 Barker Lane Chesterfield S40 1EQ for Ms Andrea Collins

(d)  Partial Discharge of Conditions

CHE/21/00175/DOC

Discharge of planning conditions 8 (site compound), 10 (desk top study) and 11 (landscaping, boundary treatments etc) of CHE/20/00456/FUL - Erection of a detached dwelling at 58A Coronation Road Brimington Chesterfield S43 1EX for Mr Andrew Doherty

(e)   CLOPUD Granted

CHE/21/00165/CLO

Erection of a single storey rear extension at 11 Heathfield Avenue Chesterfield S40 4AJ for Mrs M Woodbine

(f)   Split Decision with Conditions

CHE/21/00268/TPO

Oak - crown reduction of approximately 1.5 - 2m .  Hawthorn (part of G2) crown reduction of approximately 1.5 - 2m.  Severing of Ivy at base of both trees, works to allow more light and less foliage onto property at 67 Pomegranate Road Newbold Derbyshire S41 7BL for Mrs Lucy Buckley

CHE/21/00291/TPO

Pine Tree (T7) - fell this tree and replace it with a younger, smaller tree in the same area of the property.  If felling is not to be allowed, then we would like to greatly reduce the overall size of this tree in height and width.  Horse Chestnut Tree (T5) - we would like to reduce the overall size and thin out the branches to allow more light to reach our garden as during the summer, when in leaf, it can be very oppressive and creates a lot of debris at 15 Penmore Lane Hasland Derbyshire S41 0SG for Mr Richard Bond

CHE/21/00369/TPO

Removal of overhanging branches and crown reduction of 90% of T1 and T2 (oaks) at 9 Sedbergh Crescent Newbold Derbyshire S41 8DY for MIss Lindsey Moore

(g)  Planning Permission Required

CHE/21/00282/PA

Prior approval - For the erection of a first floor extension to existing bungalow, to a maximum ridge height of 8.753m from an existing ridge height of 5.847m at 4 Woodland Walk Holme Hall Chesterfield S40 4YB for Mrs J Lankford

(h)  Prior Approval not Required

CHE/21/00325/DEM

Demolition of the concrete multi span bridge spanning the Doe Lea River and rail corridors to the east of the former Markham Colliery Site at Markham Colliery North Tip Bridge Doe Lea River/rail Crossing Off Markham Lane Duckamnton Chesterfield S44 5HY for Derbyshire County Council

(i)  Conditional Consent for Non-material Amendment

CHE/21/00335/NMA

Amendment to approved layout to provide an access point from the end of the private drive adjacent to plots 58-60 in respect of planning permission reference CHE/20/00543/REM1 for the development of 106 residential dwellings at land at entrance to Cammac Coal Dunston Road Chesterfield Derbyshire for Strata

CHE/21/00399/NMA

Non material amendment to CHE/20/00305/FUL (Erection of new residential dwellings at the sites off Whitecotes Lane and Harehill Road with associated access, parking and open space)  to allow alterations to house types, alterations to site layout and creation of access road for Yorkshire Water tanker in southern corner of Harehill Road at land south of Walton Hospital Harehill Road Grangewood Derbyshire for Vistry Partnerships

(j)  Withdrawn

CHE/21/00443/TPO

Crown reduction on western side 2-4 metres to stop dominance over garden at 159 Old Hall Road Chesterfield S40 1HG for Miss Tracey Hume